Michael Zwaagstra: Plight of distinctive Vancouver college underscores want for selection

Article content material

Final week, a bunch of fogeys and former college students of Very best Mini Faculty spoke at a Vancouver Faculty Board (VSB) assembly, decrying a current VSB choice to relocate the varsity from its present standalone constructing in Marpole to Sir Winston Churchill Secondary, a a lot bigger facility. Mother and father and college students fear this would be the loss of life knell of Very best’s distinctive studying atmosphere since it should now share house with one other college and lots of extra college students.

Article content material

Certainly, Very best has an uncommon identify and an much more distinctive program. It’s a small highschool the place lecturers and college students are on a primary identify foundation. There’s widespread integration between grades, and “college conferences” occur regularly. Guests will discover there are not any bells all through the varsity day.

Article content material

Clearly, Very best isn’t preferrred for everybody. College students who want a extra conventional educational atmosphere will probably not be comfy on this college. Nevertheless, Very best isn’t making an attempt to be all issues to all folks — it is aware of what kind of scholars it seeks to draw, and tailors its programming accordingly.

Sadly, Very best won’t be round for much longer, no less than not in its present kind. The Vancouver college board (VSB), which Very best is a part of, plans to relocate this college from its present stand-alone constructing to Sir Winston Churchill Secondary, a a lot bigger establishment. Mother and father and college students fear this would be the death-knell of Very best’s distinctive studying atmosphere since it should now share house with one other college and lots of of extra college students.

Article content material

Article content material

This relocation has nothing to do with what’s finest for the scholars or dad and mom of Very best. Relatively, the VSB is shifting Very best to make room for college students from a close-by elementary college that’s rising. Whereas this choice is little question irritating to Very best’s studying neighborhood, it’s comprehensible. As Spock the Vulcan would say: “The wants of the various outweigh the wants of the few — or the one.”

Utilitarian decision-making is a mainstay of huge organizations, together with public college boards. Trustees don’t have the luxurious of prioritizing the wants of a comparatively small college after they have a lot bigger faculties with equally essential wants and restricted funds at their disposal. Thus, whereas public college boards might permit some specialised faculties inside their jurisdiction to function, these faculties will at all times be on the mercy of the forms.

Article content material

For this reason we shouldn’t depend on public college boards to offer satisfactory selections to folks and college students. The one means to make sure the persevering with viability of specialised faculties is to permit them to exist outdoors the general public system.

For instance, Alberta is the one province to permit constitution faculties. Constitution faculties are publicly funded and function independently from any college board. They’ll’t cost tuition charges and should adhere to the provincial curriculum. At the moment, there are 34 constitution faculties in Alberta.

The Boyle Avenue Schooling Centre is an Edmonton constitution college that makes a speciality of trauma-informed schooling. Greater than 90 per cent of scholars at Boyle are Indigenous, and the varsity makes use of a wraparound help mannequin primarily based on the medication wheel. Like Very best Mini Faculty, Boyle has a small pupil physique and locations a robust emphasis on neighborhood connections.

Article content material

If Boyle was a part of a public college board, it could be liable to having its pursuits overridden by bigger faculties. Happily, Boyle operates independently and has its personal board of administrators. After all, these board members focus solely on Boyle and may make sure that Boyle’s pursuits at all times take prime precedence. Thus, there’s no danger of Boyle being forcibly relocated to make means for an additional college neighborhood.

Take into account what might occur if the B.C. authorities handed constitution faculties laws like what Alberta already has. If dad and mom felt the VSB wasn’t taking their pursuits into consideration, they may apply to begin a constitution college primarily based on the values at Very best. They might kind their very own board and make their very own choices.

Article content material

In actuality, the cookie-cutter mannequin of public schooling doesn’t work for everybody. Some college students want a special kind of studying atmosphere. Counting on public college boards to offer satisfactory choices to those college students units them up for failure. When push involves shove, trustees will at all times put the wants of the various forward of the wants of the few.

Solely by permitting for choices akin to constitution faculties can we make sure that dad and mom discover a college that works finest for his or her kids. That is one circumstance the place the wants of the few should not be missed.

Michael Zwaagstra is a public highschool trainer and a senior fellow on the Fraser Institute.

Extra information, fewer adverts: Our in-depth journalism is feasible because of the help of our subscribers. For simply $3.50 per week, you will get limitless, ad-lite entry to The Vancouver Solar, The Province, Nationwide Publish and 13 different Canadian information websites. Help us by subscribing at the moment: The Vancouver Solar | The Province.