Opinion: Why B.C. has ended letter grades for college students in kindergarten to Grade 9

Opinion: Many are involved that college students will lose their aggressive edge, however scale-based evaluation asks college students to think about their aggressive relationship with themselves first, earlier than contemplating it with others.

Article content material

B.C.’s transfer away from letter grades for college students between kindergarten and Grade 9 is producing nervousness, and has been opposed by some dad and mom and lecturers.

Commercial 2

Article content material

In lieu of a letter-grade system, the province will use a proficiency scale to evaluate college students as much as Grade 9. The proficiency scale mannequin was first piloted in 2016-17, and for the primary time this fall all B.C. faculty districts will implement it on report playing cards.

Article content material

The modifications replicate bigger paradigm shifts in schooling. However for many individuals, letting go of the older mannequin just isn’t simple.

Anxiousness and discomfort about this main change may very well be alleviated by unpacking the rationale behind it.

Curriculum overhaul

B.C.’s public faculty schooling system has been present process an overhaul since 2010.

Roots of this transformation lie within the shifting wants of the financial system, away from industrialization and in the direction of a extra “technologically-rich” world.

Commercial 3

Article content material

The transfer to proficiency scale evaluation is one facet of this bigger transformation. The dimensions visualizes studying as a continuum, the place college students progress by the levels of Rising, Creating, Proficient and Extending.

The rationale

The centrepiece of B.C.’s new curriculum is a set of core competencies — cross-curricular proficiencies for college students in communication, vital considering and social-emotional consciousness and relations. Lecturers will use the dimensions to evaluate how college students are doing in creating these competencies.

The dimensions operates from a strengths-based perspective that views all college students as coming to high school with inherent expertise. Classroom studying seeks to construct upon this.

Proficiency scale evaluation regards studying as ongoing, whereas the letter grade and percentages system considered studying as an occasion with a particular finish.

Article content material

Commercial 4

Article content material

Letter grades: highlighting college students’ deficits

Letter grades and percentages place some college students (with As or Bs) as having strengths, whereas different college students (with Cs or Ds) are considered not even being on the continuum of studying. Letter grades spotlight the deficits of underperforming college students, thereby perpetuating a self-fulfilling prophecy of kinds. In addition they solely give a snapshot of present achievement.

In contrast, scale-style evaluation presents a broader outlook as a result of it considers scholar studying over time. With the brand new curriculum, scores on exams usually are not all that matter. Lecturers are inspired to assign equal worth to all the educational that occurs between exams, together with by formative and descriptive suggestions that college students subsequently replicate upon and implement to additional refine their work.

Commercial 5

Article content material

Many educators observe that steady descriptive suggestions is more practical in serving to college students concretely perceive their strengths and shortcomings.

Though letter grades had the looks of being definitive, they had been ambiguous — college students obtained the very seen stamp of a letter grade or proportion, however had little understanding of how that grade got here to be.

Strategy of studying

An important facet of the proficiency scale is its give attention to the method of studying itself.

For instance, a scholar’s place on the dimensions in Language Arts is decided by extra complete measures that embody:

• trainer observations of how nicely the scholar understands and may apply ideas;

• conversations with the scholar wherein the scholar communicates their understanding of a given idea;

Commercial 6

Article content material

• class actions/assignments the place the scholar will get to use the idea and refine its utilization;

• any formal assessments, which will not be exams however moderately initiatives the place the scholar will get to robustly present their studying by integrating varied ideas.

B.C.’s scale-based evaluation helps college students to not solely perceive information, but additionally the processes behind how these information come to be. By instructing college students in regards to the course of behind varied ideas, the intention is that they may be capable of switch these expertise throughout varied areas of education, which beforehand had been topic particular.

Specific criticisms, questions

One supply of parental nervousness pertains to the sensation that the dimensions is subjective and unclear. To this finish, all types of evaluation and reporting are subjective to some extent. Scale-based evaluation, by its use of descriptive suggestions, hopes to make clear the premise of evaluation.

Commercial 7

Article content material

I’ve heard different dad and mom categorical concern across the flip-flop between how the dimensions is utilized in kindergarten to Grade 9, however not in Grades 10 by 12 or post-secondary establishments.

They surprise: How will kids in B.C. fare when, for the primary 10 years of their schooling expertise, they had been assessed utilizing the proficiency scale, solely to should revert to letter grades for Grades 10 by 12 and post-secondary?

They’re additionally involved that the proficiency scale might trigger college students to lose their aggressive edge, on condition that it values impartial studying over competitors.

Scale-based evaluation doesn’t essentially ignore competitors. As a substitute, it asks college students to think about their aggressive relationship with themselves first, earlier than contemplating it with others.

Commercial 8

Article content material

Face-to-face conversations wanted

My distinctive vantage level as each an educator and researcher permits me to see how insurance policies translate in residing school rooms and within the public at giant. I’ve a useful tip for the Ministry and faculties, and this pertains to communication.

The anxieties of stakeholders largely relate to individuals not understanding the rationale behind this alteration or the way to interpret it. Some nervousness and criticism in regards to the change is grounded in how entrenched letter grades have been in B.C.’s schooling system — and certainly, in mainstream western schooling.

The ministry, faculty district leaders, principals and educators have to do a greater job speaking the intentions of this alteration. On-line data could also be useful, however ongoing old style face-to-face dialog can also be required.

Dad and mom, particularly dad and mom of English-language learners, have to instantly hear from lecturers and directors by way of open homes or mum or dad advisory councils due to the fog which surrounds this alteration.

Lifting this fog and bringing B.C.’s Proficiency Scale out from the shadows and into the daylight will probably cut back anxieties and enhance its acceptance as an efficient instrument for studying.

Victor Brar is adjunct professor, College of Training, on the College of B.C.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail for those who obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a person you observe feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra data and particulars on the way to regulate your e mail settings.

Be a part of the Dialog

Commercial 1